For-profit fitness center lobbyists take fresh run at property tax exemption

Skeptics consider dash-for-cash House bill to be unwarranted

By: - March 24, 2021 3:21 am
Former Congresswoman Lynn Jenkins, center, renews a lobbying appeal in the Kansas House for a property tax exemption for the for-profit fitness club industry statewide. (Tim Carpenter/Kansas Reflector)

Former Congresswoman Lynn Jenkins, center, renews a lobbying appeal in the Kansas House for a property tax exemption for the for-profit fitness club industry statewide. (Tim Carpenter/Kansas Reflector)

TOPEKA — Congresswoman-turned-lobbyist Lynn Jenkins renewed an effort to muscle across the political finish line a bill delivering to for-profit fitness clubs in Kansas the same property tax exemption relied upon by charitable or educational organizations.

The campaign to deliver this unprecedented tax break began in 2013 when executives of Genesis Fitness Clubs, based in Wichita, hired a tag-team of lobbyists and leveraged donations to dozens of House and Senate members. That bid fizzled in 2014, but the effort was renewed in January with Jenkins taking charge of selling the idea to legislators on behalf of Genesis and other privately owned clubs in the Kansas Health and Fitness Association. The quest is to blur the distinction for property tax purposes between a nonprofit YWCA and for-profit Genesis.

Lynn Jenkins, working as a lobbyist in her post-Congress career, resumed the fight Tuesday to convince the 2021 Legislature to buy into a bill delivering a property tax exemption to for-profit fitness centers operating in Kansas. (Sherman Smith/Kansas Reflector)

Jenkins initially tried to insert the fitness-club exemption into a Senate tax transparency bill, but that floundered after Kansas Reflector reported Genesis had neglected to pay at least $549,000 in property taxes owed in Johnson, Douglas and Shawnee counties.

On Tuesday, she told legislators her clients were uniquely deserving of the exemption because too many YWCAs and municipal recreational facilities were operating in Kansas.

While the bill would help the bottom line of for-profit fitness businesses by shedding property tax payments, Jenkins and other advocates of the bill also indicated a legitimate argument could be made for exempting these companies from sales tax.

“These facilities fully expect a competitive industry. Increasingly, their competition isn’t private-sector clubs, but government-owned health clubs that pay no taxes at all,” Jenkins said. “We think fairness is equality across the board. But we’re not here, honestly, seeking fairness. We’re just trying to correct one small piece, and that’s the property tax.'”

Jenkins’ incarnation of reform sits in House Bill 2445, which was introduced Friday and subject of the House Tax Committee hearing Tuesday. The Kansas Department of Revenue couldn’t estimate potential loss of tax revenue, but cities, counties and the state could potentially lose millions of dollars annually.

The narrowly targeted exemption outlined in the bill for fitness business wouldn’t extend to weight-control facilities, health spas, dance studios, martial arts facilities, self-defense studios nor tennis, racquet or basketball facilities, swimming pools and golf clubs.

 

Real money

Stuart Little, representing the cities of Mission, Merriam, Prairie Village and Westwood in Johnson County, expressed opposition to the bill by exploring how the Genesis facility in Merriam would benefit from avoidance of property taxes and how entities making use of those tax dollars would suffer. The company’s fitness facility in Merriam was obligated to pay $81,000 annually in local property taxes, he said. Of that total, $18,000 would go to the city of Merriam and $36,000 would be forwarded to local public schools.

Trey Cocking, deputy director of the Kansas League of Municipalities, said House Bill 2445 exempting for-profit fitness clubs from the property tax would make it difficult for cities to deliver affordable services to residents. (Noah Taborda/Kansas Reflector)

“Creating a property tax exemption for for-profit businesses sets a dangerous precedent that could compromise the ability of cities, school districts, special districts and other jurisdictions to collect adequate funding to provide essential services in the future,” Stuart said.

The bill also was opposed by the League of Kansas Municipalities and the Kansas Association of Counties.

“Government operations and not-for-profit organizations are not taxed since they are providing public goods and programming which anyone can access,” said Trey Cocking, deputy director of the League of Kansas Municipalities. “Absence of a profit motive allows them to focus on providing affordable programming and the ability to serve disadvantaged communities.”

Jay Hall, of the Kansas Association of Counties, said the precedent of establishing a property tax exemption for a certain for-profit corporation would fundamentally change the approach to property taxation in Kansas. Granting the exemption to fitness clubs could open the door to other sectors of the economy, he said.

“While there are differences in the types of property that are property tax exempt, there is a common thread. None of these property types are for-profit corporations,” he said.

In response, Rep. Clarke Sanders, R-Salina, and several other House members suggested modifying state law to compel nonprofits to pay property taxes. Others on the House committee said the situation faced by fitness centers wasn’t unique because there was overlap between government and private business with golf courses and meeting venues.

 

‘Fighting chance’

Jenkins said there was irony in that “struggling” for-profit fitness clubs were forced to help finance through mill levies the construction and operation of facilities controlled by recreational commissions, school districts and municipal governments. The COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated problems of for-profits like Genesis that were forced to endure closure in 2020 due to public health mandates, she said.

The owner of Genesis Health Clubs, including this facility in Lawrence, supports a proposal before the 2021 Legislature for an exemption from property taxes for owners of health clubs. (Tim Carpenter/Kansas Reflector)
Owners of Genesis Health Clubs, including this facility in Lawrence, are a leading advocate of a bill in the Kansas House relieving for-profit fitness clubs from obligations to pay property taxes. (Tim Carpenter/Kansas Reflector)

“During the closure period our competitors were able to turn off the lights, layoff employees and have minimal ongoing expenses. Taxpaying clubs, however, still had property taxes accruing,” Jenkins said.

In addition to unpaid property taxes by Genesis, however, the U.S. Small Business Administration reported four Genesis entities combined to receive $3.5 million to $8.3 million in Paycheck Protection Program loans during the pandemic. The federal COVID-19 relief law allows for full forgiveness of the loans.

The Genesis empire based in Wichita contained more than 20 facilities scattered among 13 cities in Kansas. It included more than 50 clubs in the six-state area of Kansas, Iowa, Nebraska, Missouri, Colorado and Oklahoma. Many of the Genesis clubs have been added in the past decade.

Greg Ferris, who has worked as a consultant to Genesis owner Rodney Steven and has been associated with Kansas Health and Fitness Association about 15 years, testified in support of the property tax break as he did in 2014. On Tuesday, he complained the Derby recreation commission’s property tax levy was funding operation of a recreation center. He also asserted private fitness clubs were closing at a “rapid rate.”

“This problem is not going away,” Ferris said. “When a tax-exempt facility is built and a taxpaying business closes, the state loss of revenue continues to grow.”

 

Other voices

Jeffrey Perkins, a lobbyist with the International Health, Racquet and Sportsclub Association, offered written testimony to the House committee that argued the exemption from property taxes was necessary to give health clubs in Kansas “a fighting chance to compete and survive.”

Matt Stafford, who represents the Kansas Chamber, said it made sense to offer a property tax exemption to for-profit fitness clubs because education or charitable nonprofits shouldn’t have advantages over private industry. (Tim Carpenter/Kansas Reflector)

“Even with this assistance health clubs would continue to support Kansas, providing tax revenue from sales tax and income tax,” he said.

Eric Stafford, a lobbyist with the Kansas Chamber, put the business organization’s influence behind the bill. He said government should discourage tax policy that created a nonprofit or public sector advantage over private industry.

However, Manhattan city manager Ron Fehr said the legislation could compromise tax revenue relied upon for economic development incentives. He said the House bill would create an “unfair tax advantage to a particular for-profit business sector across the state while all other applicable for-profit entities would continue paying property taxes.”

Blair Tanner, owner of Woodside in Westwood, said the measure would correct an injustice faced by investors in fitness businesses that had to deal with public or nonprofit recreational alternatives.

“Businesses understand risk,” Tanner said. “We know that we will have competition and we need to be better at what we do to survive. However, when your competition has the kinds of advantages these government-owned facilities enjoy, it is more than normal risk. Woodside is happy to compete against other health clubs. When things are equal, we know we can come out on top. However, things are not equal with city-owned facilities.”

Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

Tim Carpenter
Tim Carpenter

Tim Carpenter has reported on Kansas for 35 years. He covered the Capitol for 16 years at the Topeka Capital-Journal and previously worked for the Lawrence Journal-World and United Press International. He has been recognized for investigative reporting on Kansas government and politics. He won the Kansas Press Association's Victor Murdock Award six times. The William Allen White Foundation honored him four times with its Burton Marvin News Enterprise Award. The Kansas City Press Club twice presented him its Journalist of the Year Award and more recently its Lifetime Achievement Award. He earned an agriculture degree at Kansas State University and grew up on a small dairy and beef cattle farm in Missouri. He is an amateur woodworker and drives Studebaker cars.

MORE FROM AUTHOR